• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Test & Measurement Tips

Oscilloscopes, electronics engineering industry news, how-to EE articles and electronics resources

  • Oscilloscopes
    • Analog Oscilloscope
    • Digital Oscilloscope
    • Handheld Oscilloscope
    • Mixed-signal Oscilloscope
    • PC-based Oscilloscopes – PCO
  • Design
  • Calibration
  • Meters & Testers
  • Test Equipment
  • Suppliers
  • Video
  • EE Learning Center
  • FAQs
You are here: Home / New Articles / Can something consume energy without emitting a field?

Can something consume energy without emitting a field?

April 29, 2022 By David Herres Leave a Comment

The editorial offices of Testandmeasurementtips.com recently received a letter from an individual who headed up a group of investigators of paranormal phenomenon. It was a serious letter. To summarize, the group had concluded there was no legitimate method to record the activity of an alleged haunting. But the writer did have a question for us, prompted by a piece on gauss meters and ghost-hunting TV shows we did a few years ago. Their question: Can something consume energy without emitting a field itself?

With this question in mind, perhaps we can clarify things by reviewing what exactly causes electric and magnetic fields.

The simple answer is that electric fields are caused by electric charges, and magnetic fields are caused by electric currents.

em wavesThere can be a bit of confusion on the above points. It’s possible to find posts on the internet that seem to imply that changing electric fields cause magnetic fields and vice versa. Perhaps the easiest way of illustrating that this idea is erroneous is to examine the typical way electric and magnetic fields are depicted in physics books. The typical rendition shows sinusoidal electric and magnetic fields moving in sync with each other. But if one of these fields caused the other, one might expect to see some sort of time delay between them–say, the electric field changing first followed by some proportional change in the magnetic field. But that’s not what happens. The two kinds of fields change perfectly in step with each other.

Fundamentally, any electric charge that is moving has both an electric and a magnetic field around it. And magnetic and electric fields don’t interact. This means that the electromagnetic field from a large object made up of billions of particles is really just the sum of the individual fields of each particle. So with that in mind, the electromagnetic field detected at a given point in space is just the time-delayed effect of the position, velocity, and acceleration of a charge at an earlier time.

em dectector
An example of an EMF detector circuit, this one designed for finding frequencies in the 50 Hz to about 10 kHz range. An inductor carrying a dc current serves as the sensor. Impinging EM fields accelerate charges flowing through the inductor at the same frequency as the external field.

Moreover, the only real detectable effect of electromagnetism is that charges can exert forces on other charges. Thus instrumentation designed to detect electric or magnetic fields do so by measuring how the charges inside the instrument are affected by the EM field. In a nutshell, EM fields are created by charges and their motion. Their effects are only observable when they produce forces on other charges at some later time.

One additional point to examine is how charges in nature can be accelerated in the first place. There are numerous ways but one primary means is via thermal energy. Recall that objects retain heat via the vibrations of their atoms. Adding heat to an object makes the atoms of the object vibrate more violently. The more heat added, the more violent and the higher the frequency the vibration. Thus an object’s temperature is proportional to the vibrational frequency of the atoms in it.

planck's law
Black body radiation predicted by Planck’s law for different temperatures; 3,000 K equates to over 4,900 F. Thus radiation intensity of objects at room temperature is sub-microscopic.

Further recall that each atom has an electric field surrounding it. That electric field goes out to infinity though its intensity diminishes with distance at the rate of one over the distance squared. When an atom is vibrating, an observer some distance away will see a field intensity (i.e. a wave motion) that is moving at the same rate as the atom’s vibration. Consequently, atoms that vibrate sufficiently fast due to heat energy will eventually emit visible light frequencies. The classic example is a steel mill where metals in process glow orange and white hot.

Materials that aren’t hot enough to emit light still radiate lower frequencies. Planck’s law describes the intensity (actually the spectral density) of electromagnetic radiation that a given body emits at a given temperature when it isn’t being heated or cooled. In general, Planck’s law shows that the higher the temperature of a body the more radiation it emits at every wavelength. Conversely, relatively cool objects–those not hot enough to give off visible light–don’t emit much radiation at any frequency.

All in all, we’d have to say a clinical discussion of EM radiation tends to take the subject out of the realm of the paranormal.

You may also like:

  • music on scopes
    Making pictures from sound on an oscilloscope
  • music synthesizer
    Music synthesis and arbitrary waveform generators
  • 5G
    Will 5G be lethal?
  • no you can't detect ghosts with a gauss meter
    No, you can’t detect ghosts with a gauss meter
  • planck
    Planck’s Constant and discrete energy levels

Filed Under: FAQ, Featured, New Articles, Test Equipment Tagged With: FAQ

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Primary Sidebar

Test & Measurement Handbook


Oscilloscopes Finder

Search Millions of Parts from Thousands of Suppliers.

Search Now!
design fast globle

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Subscribe to test and measurement industry news, new oscilloscope product innovations and more.

Subscribe Today

EE TRAINING CENTER CLASSROOMS

EE Classrooms

RSS Current EDABoard.com discussions

  • kt/c noise of sample and hold
  • PS4 chip replacement not going to plan
  • What is the function of the long stub?
  • How to use of GaN Transistor gates instead of IGBT in this circuit ?
  • Help with Verilog replicate operator

RSS Current Electro-Tech-Online.com Discussions

  • Audio equalizer
  • Background of Members Here
  • Adding Current Limit Feature to a Buck Converter
  • Passthrough charging-simple but impossible to achieve?
  • Opamp ciruit

Footer

EE World Online Network

  • DesignFast
  • EE World Online
  • EDABoard
  • Electro-Tech Online
  • Analog IC Tips
  • Microcontroller Tips
  • Power Electronic Tips
  • Sensor Tips
  • Connector Tips
  • Wire and Cable Tips
  • 5G Technology World

Test & Measurement Tips

  • Subscribe to our newsletter
  • Advertise with us
  • Contact us
  • About us
Follow us on TwitterAdd us on FacebookFollow us on YouTube Follow us on Instagram

Copyright © 2022 · WTWH Media LLC and its licensors. All rights reserved.
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of WTWH Media.

Privacy Policy